START WITH SCRIPTURE:
Matthew 15:21-28
CLICK HERE TO READ SCRIPTURE ON BIBLEGATEWAY.COM
OBSERVE:
Jesus continues his healing ministry — only now he is no longer in Jewish Galilee. He has departed from Gennesaret (just south of Capernaum, on the Sea of Galilee) and has withdrawn into the region of Tyre and Sidon to the north. He seems to be seeking respite from the pressures of Herod (Matthew 14:1-13), the needs of the multitudes (Matthew 14:14-21, 35-36), and the controversies of the Pharisees and scribes who have come all the way from Jerusalem to interrogate him (Matthew 15:1-14). Perhaps he hopes to be a bit more anonymous as he moves out of Jewish territory into a pagan land.
However, even in Phoenicia, on the coast of the Mediterranean Sea, the reputation of Jesus precedes him. A Canaanite woman recognizes him. Canaan was identified with the land of the Phoenicians.
And this Gentile Canaanite is aware of the heritage of Jesus. She cries out:
Have mercy on me, Lord, you son of David! My daughter is severely possessed by a demon!
This is historically significant. We are reminded that David was the king of the united kingdoms of Israel and Judah. David enjoyed unusual success as a monarch, and became the Biblical standard of a good king despite a serious moral lapse. He was promised an eternal royal dynasty by God. Thus, a pagan woman who recognizes that Jesus is a descendant of David suggests her awareness of Hebrew prophecies concerning the Messiah.
But a Jewish reader would have said — the son of David is our Messiah, not yours! The attitudes of Jews toward Canaanites were the same that they had toward Samaritans, Greeks or Romans — they were all Gentiles, and hence unclean.
Jesus seems at first to confirm this prejudice:
But he answered her not a word.
Jesus, who is normally described as a compassionate healer everywhere he goes, ignores this woman and her demon-possessed daughter.
Evidently the Canaanite woman is quite persistent. She begins to annoy the disciples who beg him:
Send her away; for she cries after us.
It seems that what they are really saying to Jesus is “give her what she wants! She won’t leave us alone.”
Again, Jesus’ response seems out of character:
I wasn’t sent to anyone but the lost sheep of the house of Israel.
We remember that when he commissioned his disciples to go out in his name, preaching the Good News, healing and casting out demons, he was very specific:
Jesus sent these twelve out, and commanded them, saying, “Don’t go among the Gentiles, and don’t enter into any city of the Samaritans. Rather, go to the lost sheep of the house of Israel (Matthew 10:5-6).
If anything, Jesus was making it clear that his first priority at this point in his ministry is to reconcile to God those Jews who had strayed from the faith. We know from reading the rest of the story that the ministry to the Gentiles will come, but later. First things first.
We also know that Jesus has made some exceptions — he healed the servant of the Roman centurion from a distance (Matthew 10:5-13). He also casts out demons from two men in the region of Gergesenes, which is a Gentile region on the southeastern bank of the Sea of Galilee. Very likely the two men were Gentiles. The fact that the demons are cast into a herd of swine certainly confirms a Gentile connection — Jews wouldn’t keep pigs since they were forbidden to eat pork (Matthew 8:28-34).
But Jesus seems adamant in this account, even as this woman persists. Finally, he answers, rather harshly:
It is not appropriate to take the children’s bread and throw it to the dogs.
This is clearly an insult. Dogs in Middle Eastern cultures were not considered “man’s best friend.” Dogs were usually described as unclean scavengers. Jesus seems to be racist at best — the children are obviously the Jews, and the dogs are Gentiles!
But this woman is tenacious. She argues with Jesus!
But she said, “Yes, Lord, but even the dogs eat the crumbs which fall from their masters’ table.”
Yes, dogs may be scavengers — but they do belong to their master, and they eat what he throws them from the table! They may not be children, but they still have a place, she seems to be arguing.
Jesus responds with some astonishment, and with action:
“Woman, great is your faith! Be it done to you even as you desire.” And her daughter was healed from that hour.
Faith transcends race, class, ethnicity, even religious affiliation.
APPLY:
This is a somewhat troublesome passage. Matthew doesn’t “clean it up” for our convenience. Jesus appears to be subject to the same bigotries against Gentiles that prevailed amongst his Jewish brethren.
How is this possible? Jesus is the Son of God. He loves all the world. And at the end of Matthew’s Gospel he will commission his disciples to go into all the world and make disciples of all nations. How can he be so harsh to this pathetic woman seeking healing for her daughter? It seems so out of character!
Is it because Jesus was also fully human as well as fully God? Was he therefore influenced by the attitudes of his time, sharing even some of the prejudices of his own culture? Did his views evolve so that he became more inclusive? That might be a comforting humanistic explanation, but it still doesn’t seem to be consistent with the man who was described as worthy of worship in the previous chapter (Matthew 14:22-33).
Moreover, this episode is also inconsistent with what he has said earlier when he healed the servant of the Roman centurion. The centurion begs Jesus not to come to his home — perhaps because the Roman is aware of Jewish attitudes toward Gentiles, and doesn’t want Jesus to be compromised. Instead, he tells Jesus that as a soldier he understands authority, and all Jesus need do is issue the command and his servant will be healed. And Jesus responds to him this way:
he marveled, and said to those who followed, “Most certainly I tell you, I haven’t found so great a faith, not even in Israel. I tell you that many will come from the east and the west, and will sit down with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in the Kingdom of Heaven, but the children of the Kingdom will be thrown out into the outer darkness. There will be weeping and gnashing of teeth” (Matthew 8:10-12).
Clearly, in this account Jesus understands that there will be many Gentiles who will be saved and invited to the great wedding banquet at the end of the age, while many who assume they are included will be cast out. Jesus is obviously articulating an inclusive message about the Gentiles.
So why the initial cold shoulder with the Canaanite woman? I reject the notion that Jesus’ sensibilities somehow “evolved” over time, especially given his response to the centurion’s faith. I do believe that the spread of the Gospel was to happen in stages. I believe that this was a strategic decision, which explains why he initially told his disciples to go only to the lost sheep of Israel, and then after his resurrection commanded them to go to all the nations. But I don’t think that Jesus fundamentally changed in his attitude toward others.
Perhaps there are two possibilities. One is that Jesus is testing the Canaanite woman’s faith. Did she merely see him as a wonderworker who might help her daughter? Had she tried everything else and thought she might as well try this Jewish healer? But she proved to Jesus’ satisfaction that what motivated her wasn’t merely her desperation, but her faith in the son of David.
Another possibility is that Jesus was using this incident as a teaching moment for his own disciples. He is certainly aware of the prejudices of his own disciples. In fact, we know that even after his resurrection and after the day of Pentecost there would still be great resistance to expanding the mission to the Gentiles. It would require a direct vision from God to Peter in order to lead him to the house of Cornelius the Roman centurion (Acts 10). And a similar experience on the road to Damascus between the risen Jesus and a Jewish Pharisee named Saul would change the course of history for the ministry to the Gentiles (Acts 9).
Perhaps Jesus is teaching the disciples that they must see this woman not as an annoyance, or as an unclean Canaanite, but as a woman of great faith.
RESPOND:
The racial and ethnic attitudes that I discover in this passage about Jesus and this Canaanite woman are every bit as relevant today as they ever were. In the United States, racism has become somewhat more subtle, but there are still boundaries and barriers that exist.
When I see a woman in the grocery store wearing a burka, I have to admit that my initial reaction is still uncomfortable. And yet when I see her with her children selecting breakfast cereals, I realize that she and her family are not so unlike mine.
I really do believe that this encounter between Jesus and the Canaanite woman was meant to illustrate for us that the differences between ethnic groups shrink when we are reminded of our common humanity. This woman has a daughter whom she loves deeply, and about whom she is desperately worried. She is so concerned that she actually crosses an ethnic and religious boundary, and recognizes this son of David from whom she seeks help. And her faith is what Jesus acknowledges. Human need and faith transcend all other barriers.
Lord, I pray that you will help me look beyond my differences with people who don’t look like me or talk like me or think like me. Help me to see them as fellow human beings who need the healing and hope that you offer. Amen.
PHOTOS: "Matthew 15.27" by Baptist Union of Great Britain is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.0 Generic license.